David James Pye Convicted for Orchestrating Bikie Leader's Murder
In a landmark ruling, David James Pye has been found guilty by a Western Australian Supreme Court judge for organising the assassination of former Rebels bikie kingpin Nick Martin. The verdict was delivered on Friday morning, with Justice Joseph McGrath presiding over the case after extensive deliberations following a high-profile trial that concluded in October.
Details of the Crime and Court Proceedings
Justice McGrath determined that Pye paid a hired gun $150,000 to carry out the murder of Nick Martin at the Perth Motorplex in Kwinana more than six years ago, in December 2020. Pye appeared via video link from prison to hear the verdict, which also included guilty findings on two counts of inciting the same shooter to commit principal indictable offences. These additional charges related to allegations that Pye offered money to have Comanchero member Ray Cilli and another woman killed.
During the trial, Pye was granted strict home detention bail and placed under constant surveillance, including daily police convoys to and from the courthouse, with helicopter tracking from above. The case, dubbed the bikie trial of the century, began with a bombshell confession from prosecutor Justin Whalley, who acknowledged there was no direct evidence linking Pye to Martin's murder.
Key Testimony and Defence Arguments
The prosecution's case relied heavily on the testimony of the sniper, whose identity remains suppressed. This individual, described as a one-time mercenary and former army reservist, is currently serving a 20-year prison term for murdering Nick Martin. In exchange for a reduced sentence, he agreed to testify against Pye.
Pye's defence counsel, David Hallowes, instructed by high-profile lawyer Paul Holmes, accepted much of the prosecution's evidence as uncontroversial. However, Hallowes strongly contested the reliability and credibility of the gunman's testimony, arguing that dishonesty was inherent in his character. Despite this, the judge found the evidence sufficient to convict Pye on all charges.
Sentencing and Future Developments
David James Pye is scheduled to return to court in three months for sentencing, where the full consequences of his actions will be determined. This case has drawn significant attention due to its connections to bikie gangs and the dramatic nature of the trial proceedings. More updates are expected as the legal process continues, highlighting the ongoing efforts to address organised crime in Western Australia.
