Pensioner Triumphs in Court Over Unlawful Speeding Fine in Newcastle
A 68-year-old pensioner from Nelson Bay has successfully had a $443 speeding fine withdrawn after a protracted legal battle, exposing significant bureaucratic failures within the NSW government. Steve Barrett was fined for allegedly driving at 57km/h in a school zone on Ingall Street, Mayfield East, on August 5, despite the absence of a proper 40km/h sign.
Missing Sign Leads to Legal Dispute
Mr Barrett argued that there was no school zone sign on the left side of the road as he drove south, with signs only facing northerly drivers. After reporting the issue to the Newcastle Herald, Transport for NSW quietly installed a new end-of-school zone sign in October 2025. However, government agencies initially refused to scrap the fine, forcing Mr Barrett to take the matter to court.
"I've had to go through the NSW government's bureaucratic bullshit to get a just and common sense result," Mr Barrett stated, expressing frustration over the handling of his case.
Government Inaction and Court Intervention
Despite letters to NSW Roads and Regional Transport Minister Jenny Aitchison and Revenue NSW, the fine was upheld. Revenue NSW chief commissioner Phil Minns responded in October last year, stating that after a review, the fine could not be scrapped and suggested court action. This prompted Mr Barrett to prepare for a court hearing, where he intended to call Minister Aitchison as a defence witness.
Magistrate Peter Feather advised Mr Barrett to request a police review, leading to a letter to Police Commissioner Mal Lanyon. The NSW Police Traffic and Highway Patrol Command then acted promptly, withdrawing the fine and restoring four demerit points.
Broader Implications and Public Victory
Mr Barrett, a former journalist with major news networks, highlighted that the system breakdown could affect hundreds of other drivers. "This is where the whole NSW government system breaks down," he remarked, emphasizing the need for accountability. The resolution marks a victory for both Mr Barrett and the Newcastle Herald, which brought public attention to the issue.
Under the Road Rules 2014 (NSW), a school zone requires proper signage, and this case underscores the importance of clear regulations to prevent unjust fines. The incident serves as a reminder of the challenges individuals face when navigating government bureaucracies.
