Claremont has announced it will challenge the suspension handed down to star forward Alec Waterman for striking East Fremantle ruckman Mitch Brown during last weekend's WAFL clash. The incident occurred in the third quarter of the match at Claremont Oval, with Waterman making contact with Brown's head after a ruck contest.
Details of the Incident
The match review panel assessed the strike as intentional conduct with high impact, resulting in a three-match ban. Waterman, who has been a key player for Claremont this season, was reported for striking and subsequently accepted the initial charge but later decided to contest the severity of the penalty.
Claremont's Argument
Claremont officials argue that the contact was accidental and that Waterman had no intent to strike Brown. They will present video evidence and witness testimony to support their case. The club believes the incident warrants a reduction in the suspension to one match, citing similar cases in the WAFL that resulted in lesser penalties.
Waterman has been in impressive form, kicking 15 goals in his last five games, and his absence would be a significant blow to Claremont's finals aspirations. The club is currently sitting in fourth place on the ladder with five rounds remaining in the regular season.
Opposition Reaction
East Fremantle has not commented on the appeal, but Brown is expected to be available for selection this week after passing concussion protocols. The Sharks are also in the finals race, sitting just outside the top five.
Upcoming Tribunal Hearing
The WAFL tribunal will hear Claremont's appeal on Tuesday night. If unsuccessful, Waterman will miss crucial matches against West Perth, Subiaco, and Peel Thunder. The club is hopeful that the tribunal will take into account Waterman's clean record and the lack of injury to Brown.
This case has sparked debate among WAFL fans and pundits about the consistency of match review panel decisions. Some believe the three-match ban was excessive, while others argue that any contact to the head should be treated seriously.
Claremont coach Ashley Prescott expressed confidence in the appeal process, stating that the club has a strong case. We believe Alec deserves a fair hearing, and we are confident the tribunal will see that this was an accident, he said.
The outcome of the appeal could have significant implications for the WAFL finals race, with Claremont needing every available player to secure a top-three finish and a double chance in the playoffs.
